Madoka moves over just a little. Just leaning over enough that she can see into the bag even before he fully hands it to her. And the moment she does get a glimpse of what's inside the bag, she lets out a surprise gasp.

"Alfredo..! That's so sweet of you!"

Especially since he's in no way obligated to buy her a gift. In fact, she didn't even get him anything! Yet he bought her such a precious new friend..!

She gently reaches into the bag to take the alpaca out, holding it up like it's baby Simba a precious treasure.

"Look at it, it's so cute..!"