The sudden focus has her backpedalling more, but she hides most of her discomfort by the simple and expedient solution of not making eye contact with anyone.

"Don't worry about- uh, you're both welcome. Didn't get her name, but I met a little girl..." Who almost electrocuted herself by sticking a knife in a toaster. But she doesn't say that part. They'd just worry more, and the kid was smart enough to back off. She also doesn't mention the priestess thing, because she's got a good idea of how fast these guys pick up nicknames. "Anyway, family's family. You don't need to be related to look out for each other."