Ple Two definitely can't change Madoka's mind on this one. It's not like she'll die from withholding the chocolate for a bit longer, after all! And the joy of sharing it with someone she likes so much will more than make up for it.

Besides, it gives them a bit more time to talk about this important other topic, right? Or at the very least-- this topic that's so important to Ple Two.

"Why..? Is it because you're out of practice..?"

Granted, that's Madoka just guessing. She has no idea at all how these things work.