She has to try it now. She definitely has to. There's no way Madoka's sense of politeness will allow her to back out of this.

So she nods - though with a tense edge to it - and grabs a spoon to try and tear a spoonful of.. whatever this is. Some sort of jelly blob that isn't jelly at all at the same time.

"T-Thanks for the food.." She's even polite enough to say that before Madoka inserts the spoonful into her mouth.

.. and instantly looks like she's dying. Her face pales, and she very much looks like she has to throw up. Thankfully they're close enough to a sink that Madoka can just run over there and quickly spit it out again, since swallowing that would not have been a good idea.

And even though she spit it out, she sounds very miserable as she's just.. hanging there over the sink now.. Madoka even has her hands pressed to her mouth, as if she's worried she'll still vomit.

What was that even! That certainly wasn't food..!