Inigo's expression drops a little at that. Not too far - he doesn't look sad or anything of the sort - but he does look a little bummed. Here he was hoping that it'd taste just as good!

Though he supposes sweetness is never too bad of a thing.. so Inigo does give the plate a glance, rather than outright reject it.

"I guess I could give it a taste.." Just to make sure. Though before he does that, he glances over at them. "It's a little odd to eat some meat though without knowing where it came from, huh?"