There's one good thing about this situation - mostly Madoka being right in approaching the guy she thought seemed like a capable and responsible adult. Because Tony really is giving her the most helpful answer possible in this situation, so her first impression? Right on the spot, as far as she's concerned.

The downside, obviously, is the answer itself. First her eyes grow a little wide in surprise, then she starts frowning in worry.

"I'm sorry, but I don't think I.. came here." She pauses for a moment, obviously wrestling with figuring out what wording to use for that. Madoka has no idea just how she ended up here at all. "I just-- I was in the middle of something, and then I was suddenly here. As strange as that probably sounds.."